Got these to replace a pair of beat up Tlands, they are comfy, sized accurately and seem well made. I will need to water/stain proof them before the real winter sets in to insure that rain and snow won't seep through, I do not expect them to ever be immersion proof but splashing, rain and snow, it is expected that they keep the feet dry. Have already worn them in tall wet grass and seemed to work perfectly. These are comfy to wear all day.